Board Thread:Fun and Games/@comment-28661234-20160213000159/@comment-25355644-20160313122631

Personally, I wouldn't call Onestar a bad leader. Sure, he wasn't nice to ThunderClan, but he didn't make many objectively bad decisions as a leader. He was (is?) a good leader to WindClan, and even when you include the angle of his personality, we have no evidence that he was unpleasant to his Clan, and it was confirmed that he felt bad for the way he behaved towards the other Clans, but he realised it was the best way that he could remove any doubts that WindClan could stand on their own.

I really rant too much, don't I?